I really don't know what I'm doing when it comes to breeding in HEE and I was wondering how to know when to geld a stallion and when to keep him as a stud. I'm almost too afraid to geld the stallions I have because I feel like they may eventually produce something good, but I think because I don't geld them, my foal ratings are getting lower and lower. I've been looking through the forum to figure out how to properly match horses but the whole thing just kind of confuses me.

Stallions are very subjective to what is good and what is not. So just take what I have to say with a grain of salt :)

Ok thank you so much for that. It seems like I'm doing a lot wrong XD

Taking a look, i'd train in all disciplines. It gives an idea of if the horse is actually strong, as well as where it is strong :)

Thank you so much for your help!

Yup. Totally agree with everything that was said. I geld everything that's PEP- now.

this is my general advise on "to geld or not to geld"

<font class="mainline">This is easy to answer in each case with one question:

Do YOU think that this boy will be able to really improve yor stable rating or color wise (in 2 gameyears for a colt) - or do you think there are other boys out there for brood, decent in price and more obviousely the better producers than this one....

No matter what you are breeding for and not matter if you are a new or experienced stable.
No matter which rating the horse has or which color genetics.
No matter what you are told in chat or by your friends.


A show gelding can win up to 350k and more in his lifetime and is the best support your stable can have ;)

But its always up to YOU and your way of gameplay if you want to geld or keep intact :D