Is average and superb for a foundation (wild) a good place to start?

For a second gen (wildXwild) would superb be good?

For 3rd (2ndX2nd) premium and superb?

It's so hard as a new player to breed decent babies when premium and elite are the only thing that people talk about

Here's my 2nd gen supsupsup colt that I'm not sure is good or bad. I really liked him

https://horseeden.com/horse.php?id=17220944

Ideally you want nothing below a P to start a pedigree, but it’s different for everyone.

I wish you luck :)

(I posted this on the wrong account) I was referencing my main ‘Fox Crest Manor’

If you are starting from wild lines and breeding that low of a rating it's likely going to take quite a bit to get your horses strong, many more generations than you have posted. But "good" is also how you choose to define it. By game standards no, the horse pictured isn't a good one...he is neither a good rating or a rare color. In addition he's PON, which is a bit of a weak breed anyway, so he's probably not even going to reproduce his own rating much unless you toss him at stronger mares. But if you like him and want to keep him for breeding there's nothing wrong with it if you have patience. Or you could geld him and use him as a show horse.

Depending on breed, PPP and PEP combo mares can be very affordable for new players. I personally started just breeding for PPP combos, which eventually turned into E horses as generations passed. Most of my homebred EEE horses trace to a single PPP mare. Even PEE/EEP mares are affordable...I bought an EEE producing one for 6,000 (that's an extreme example and I got lucky, but it happened). And if you want wilds specifically, I bought a wild X PEE mare (she was rated so definitely sold as PEE) for 25k. Again, just need some patience and to comb the sales for what you are looking for.